440 COTTAGE COURT, Marco Island, FL 34145 (MLS# 2252362)

Island Location: Tiger Tail Beach

Community: Marco Island

Subarea Type: Water Indirect

Property SubType: Single Family Residence

Listing Contract Date: 2025-11-29

List Price: $2,900,000

Current Price: $2,900,000

Tax Unit: 12

Tax Block: 392

Tax Lot: 10

Parcel Number: 58051480003

Tax Annual Amount: 19003

Tax Year: 2025

Special Assessment: No

Furnished: Turnkey

Flood Plain: Yes

A/C SqFt: 3571

Bathrooms Half: 0

Lot Size Dimensions: 96x116x147x116

Stories: 2

Total Baths: 4

# Office Den: 0

Rear Exposure: Northwest

Garage Spaces: 2

Boat Dock: Yes

Boat Lift: Yes

Pool Private Y/N: Yes

Spa Y/N: Yes

Acres: 0.26

HOA Y/N: No

Total Area-SqFt: 5746

Year Built: 1992

Bedrooms Total: 5

Bathrooms Full: 4

Public Remarks: Discover island living with timeless style in this West Indies/Key West-inspired coastal retreat tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac. This fabulous home blends classic tropical architecture with relaxed coastal elegance, creating an inviting, breezy atmosphere. The exterior showcases crisp architectural details, a metal roofline, and lush tropical landscaping. Inside abundant and plentiful natural light fills the living space, where vaulted ceilings and refined finishes strike the ideal balance between Caribbean sophistication and Key West casual comfort. The main living area with fireplace flows effortlessly into a beautifully designed kitchen, making it ideal for both entertaining and everyday living. Multiple sets of French doors open to your private outdoor oasis, with a sparkling pool, covered seating areas, and swaying palms, an idyllic backdrop for al fresco dining, relaxation, and gatherings with friends and family. For boating enthusiasts, this property is a dream. Other features include 3 new AC units, 2 new in 2025 and the 3rd less than two years old; Wolf and SubZero high-end appliances; wine cooler and beverage center in kitchen; spacious 2-car garage; the 3rd full guest bath has been recently added, and two other guest baths have recently been remodeled. All this plus147' of water frontage, private boat dock with room for two boats and wave runners, with electric available right at the dock. The thoughtful floor plan includes two separate stairways leading to the second floor. One stairway brings you to the upstairs bedroom wing, where each bedroom features its own private balcony with outstanding views, creating an elevated and serene retreat for family and visitors. This level also includes the expansive master suite, complete with a double-sided fireplace shared with the spa-inspired master bathroom, adding warmth and luxury to both spaces. The second stairway leads to a spacious recreation room, currently used as a pool room, that also functions perfectly as a game room, media room, or flexible space tailored to your lifestyle. Practicality meets style in the well-appointed laundry room, featuring a laundry tub, front-load washer and dryer, and a generous amount of built-in cabinetry for excellent storage. Guest rooms are designed for comfort and privacy, making hosting effortless. Located just minutes from Marco Island's world-famous beaches, popular restaurants, and boutique shopping, this residence offers a rare blend of charm, character, and modern coastal living. A standout residence where West Indies elegance meets Key West warmth—this home delivers an unforgettable island lifestyle in one of Marco Island's most desirable neighborhoods.

Road Frontage Length: 96

Water Front Footage: 147

Coastal: 1

None Available: 1

Dishwasher: 1

Disposal: 1

Dryer: 1

Microwave: 1

Oven: 1

Range: 1

Refrigerator: 1

Washer: 1

None: 1

None: 1

100+ Ft: 1

Vinyl Siding: 1

Wood Frame: 1

Central Air: 1

At Close: 1

Buyer Obtain Mortgage: 1

Cash: 1

Central Heating: 1

Electric: 1

Deeded: 1

Deck: 1

Breakfast Bar: 1

Eat-in Kitchen: 1

Natural Stone: 1

Tile: 1

Wood: 1

Cul-De-Sac: 1

Built-in Features: 1

Custom Cabinets: 1

French Doors: 1

Gas Fireplace: 1

Walk-In Closet(s): 1

Electric Dryer Hookup: 1

Inside: 1

Washer Hookup: 1

Attached: 1

Garage: 1

Garage Door Opener: 1

Private: 1

Resale: 1

Metal: 1

Security System: 1

Sewer Central: 1

City: 1

Public: 1

Two: 1

Lanai: Open

Porch: Open

Listing Agent has no Relationship with Seller: 1

Double Vanity: 1

Shower Only: 1

City: 1

County: 1

Architectural Plans: 1

Bay: 1

Access Gulf: 1

Access Lift: 1

Access Private Dock: 1

Impact Doors: 1

Impact Windows: 1

Electric Heat: 1

In-Ground: 1

Street Number: 440

Street Name: COTTAGE

Street Suffix: COURT

County: Collier

State: FL

Postal Code: 34145

Subdivision Name: Marco Beach Unit 12

Status: Active